The Secret Menu Items That Are Actually Worth It

Fast food secret menus aren’t exactly secret anymore—but that doesn’t make them any less exciting. From off-menu hacks at In-N-Out to custom creations at Starbucks, these items often deliver more flavor, creativity, and value than what’s printed on the board. But not every hidden gem lives up to the hype. Here’s a look at the secret menu items that are actually worth ordering—and how to get them right.

1. In-N-Out: Animal Style Fries and Burgers
   Possibly the most famous “secret” order in America, In-N-Out’s Animal Style option adds grilled onions, pickles, extra spread, and mustard-cooked patties to your burger—or cheese, grilled onions, and spread to your fries. It’s messy, rich, and absolutely worth the upgrade.
   Visit In-N-Out
2. Chipotle: The Quesarito
   The legendary Quesarito is a burrito wrapped in a melted cheese quesadilla instead of a regular tortilla. While not always available in-store due to prep time, it’s often accessible when ordering through the Chipotle app. It’s extra indulgent and perfect for big appetites.
3. Starbucks: The Pink Drink Remix
   Starbucks secret menu drinks have gone viral on TikTok for a reason. The Pink Drink with vanilla cold foam and a splash of matcha is a sweet, creamy upgrade that’s not officially on the menu but can be easily customized. Just enter the modifications manually in the customizations section.
4. McDonald’s: Land, Air & Sea
   This behemoth stacks a Big Mac, McChicken, and Filet-O-Fish into one sandwich. While McDonald’s briefly offered this combo as part of a marketing campaign, you can still build it manually. Order the three sandwiches individually and stack them yourself—or ask nicely at the counter.
   McDonald’s Menu
5. Taco Bell: The Incredible Hulk
   This creative twist on the 5-Layer Burrito replaces nacho cheese with guacamole and removes the inner tortilla. It’s a lighter, fresher take on a fan favorite and still packs major flavor. Ask for a 5-Layer Burrito with these swaps at participating Taco Bell locations.
   Order from Taco Bell
6. Shake Shack: Peanut Butter & Bacon Burger
   A true throwback, this off-menu Shake Shack order combines bacon with peanut butter sauce for a sweet-salty hit. While not always available, some locations will accommodate it if they have both ingredients on hand. Pro tip: order bacon on a ShackBurger and add a side of peanut butter from dessert toppings.
   Shake Shack Locations
7. Wendy’s: Barnyard Burger
   Ask for a combination of beef, spicy chicken, and bacon on a single sandwich. While not officially listed, this protein-packed Barnyard Burger is beloved by longtime fans. Customize through the Wendy’s app or in person with a smile.

Ordering Tips for Secret Menu Success

• Use the app when possible: Some custom items are easier to build using mobile order apps, where you can add or remove ingredients manually.

• Be clear and polite: Many items require staff to go off-script. Being specific and courteous helps your chances.

• Expect variation: Not all locations are equipped or willing to make secret menu items, especially during peak hours.

Conclusion

Secret menus let fast food fans explore creativity and flavor beyond standard combos. Whether you’re adding guac to a burrito or remixing a milkshake, these off-menu options can make your next visit more memorable. Just remember—secret doesn’t mean guaranteed, so bring some flexibility and fun to your order.